Executive Summaries Jun 9, 2023

Non-Compliance Clauses in Construction Contracts: When Do They Apply?

When it comes to major construction projects, many construction contracts stipulate that the general contractor responsible for the work is liable to pay substantial penalties should they fail to meet the agreed deadlines.

In fact, managing and meeting deadlines is a key obligation under the contract between the contractor and the client. However, fulfilling this obligation is subject to several uncertainties, including:

  • the accuracy of the information provided by the client;
  • unforeseen circumstances during the project;
  • the proper fulfillment by other parties involved in the project of their own obligations.

Failure to meet deadlines can have a significant impact on the client. As such, many choose to include a contractual clause facilitating compensation should deadlines not be met.

Although failure to meet deadlines can be the subject of a claim by the client without being explicitly stipulated in the contract, penal clauses for delays are not uncommon in construction contracts. Such clauses also anticipate the assessment of damages that may be claimed should the contractor fail to meet the deadline. The law specifically provides for such clauses known as “penal clauses.”

A penal clause provides contractual means of determining ahead of time the financial compensation to which a party will be entitled to, should the other party fail to meet their obligations (e.g. failure to meet the deadlines). Although not immune to legal challenges, and subject to judicial moderation, the penal clause for failure to meet deadlines can make it easier for the client to claim such damages, notably by contractually fixing the value of such damages in advance between the parties.

On this point, however, the Court of Appeal of Québec highlights that the existence of a penal clause does not always allow the claim of the damages provided for therein. The Court may require a prima facie proof of prejudice to the party invoking the penal clause[1], and refuse to apply it, if failure to perform by the defaulting co-contractor does not cause prejudice to the party invoking the application of such clause.

Recent Examples of Limits to the Penal Clause for Failure to Meet Deadlines

In December 2022, the Court of Appeal of Québec ruled that the City of Québec was not entitled to claim compensation under a penal clause for failure to meet deadlines from the general contractor responsible for the construction of a waterworks project requiring the installation of a freestanding footbridge[2].

According to the Court, the City of Québec contributed significantly to the late delivery of the work by failing to fulfill its obligation to provide information, specifically by failing to sufficiently describe the planned work in its tender documents, thereby misleading those involved in the project as to its actual complexity and costs.

In fact, when the call for tenders was issued, the project design had not yet been finalized, and the bidders had to deal with the design and construction of an unpredictable project. Insofar as the City of Québec had enlisted the help of experts to design the preliminary as well as final plans and specifications for such a project, the Court of Appeal found that the bidders could rely on the City’s assessment of the project’s feasibility and on the information obtained.

Accordingly, the Court found that the various parties involved were deprived of key information in the preparation of their bids, and that the City of Québec could not, therefore, blame them for the failure to meet the deadline and the increase in costs. Given the City’s primary role in the failure to meet deadlines, they could not complain about the delays and seek the application of the penal clause and related penalties.

This ruling also illustrates how the lack of prejudice would have prevented the application of the penal clause. The Court of Appeal emphasized that, had it not been for the City of Québec’s failure to meet their obligation to provide information, the penal clause would still not have applied, as the City had failed to show that they had suffered damages as a result of such delay. In the Court’s view, it was not enough for the City of Québec to invoke without qualification their contractual right to be compensated for the delay in the execution of the work. Moreover, should a party seeking to enforce a penal clause be able to prove that no prejudice was suffered by their client despite the failure to meet deadlines, it will generally be impossible to enforce the clause.

Continuing on the subject of penal clauses, last November, the Court of Appeal upheld a Superior Court judgment highlighting another limitation to the application of a failure to meet deadlines clause[3]. This time around, the Court of Appeal ruled that the City of Montréal was not entitled to invoke the penalty for delay against a construction company responsible for expanding and upgrading an arena, since the latter had previously indicated they would not avail themselves of the clause.

It is worth noting that the penal clause in this case did not appear to apply automatically, leaving the City of Montréal free to decide how to use it. Evidence thus revealed that the City of Montréal had implied, through their director (during the project and even after the legal proceedings had been initiated), that they had no intention of applying the delay penalties if the contractor showed goodwill during the project. For reasons of consistency and good faith, therefore, the City could not seek the application of the clause.

In conclusion, penal clauses included in construction contracts that provide for the assessment of penalties applicable in case of delay in the execution of work are common and can give rise to legal challenges. Caution should be exercised before automatically concluding that such penalties apply. The above-mentioned decisions clearly illustrate that it is sometimes possible for a contractor who is subject to such a clause to challenge its application, depending on the specific circumstances of the work in progress.

Do not hesitate to contact our construction litigation team, who will be pleased to provide you with advice and support.

 

[1] See Robitaille v. Gestion L. Jalbert Inc. 2007 QCCA 1052, par. 44 and  seq. and Gestess Plus (9088-0964 Québec Inc.) v. Harvey 2008 QCCA 314, par. 17 and  seq. and [2] Québec City v. Constructions BSL Inc, 2022 QCCA 1682 ("BSL" Decision). and [3] City of Montréal v. Construction Company Édilbec Inc. 2022 QCCA 1521 ("Édilbec" Decision).

Stay on the lookout!

Subscribe to our communications and benefit from our market knowledge to identify new business opportunities, learn about innovative best practices and receive the latest developments. Discover our exclusive thought leadership and events.

Subscribe

You would also like

court

When Announcing a Price Comes at a Cost: The Court of Appeal Rules on Damages in Union des consommateurs v. Air Canada

BCF Recognized in the 2025 Edition of Benchmark Litigation Canada

lexpert

27 BCF Professionals Stand Out in the Canadian Legal Lexpert Directory 2025

Lexology

6 BCF Professionals Recognized in Lexology Index Canada 2024

contrat

RBQ Resumes Investigation into Armoires PMM

Entrepreneurship forum

Entrepreneurship Forum: Vision 2025

construction site

Preservation of the right to a construction legal hypothec: What Is the Impact of a Contract Termination?

Tech Forum 360

Tech 360 Forum: Growth and Inflection Points

Contractor Liability for Ground Defects Leading to Loss of the Work

Droit

E-Power Resources Inc. Secures Major Victory Against Dissident Shareholders

lexpert

28 Professionals Stand Out in the Canadian Legal Lexpert Directory 2024

Prospera: Québec’s Economic Barometer

Canada's Best Managed Companies: BCF Recognized for 17th Consecutive Year

Contruction meeting

Site extensions : how do you build a solid claim?

stephanie-la-rocque

Stéphanie La Rocque Appointed to the Court of Québec

Victory for Développements St-Antoine as the Expropriated Party is Fully Compensated

Contractors: Why Is It Important for You to Be Directly Involved in the Work?

new-partners-2024

BCF Has Appointed Three New Partners

andre-ryan-client-choice

André Ryan Wins the Prestigious Client Choice Awards for 2023

Construction Work: An Additional Liability for Owner-Employers

Non-compliance with the Contractual Claims Procedure: a Fatality for Contractors?

Who’s Who Legal : 5 BCF Professionals Stand Out

BCF extends its Partnership with the Canadian Association of Black Lawyers to a Third Year

annie-claude-trudeau-rising-star-en

Annie-Claude Trudeau Honoured as a 2023 Lexpert Rising Star

Can Shareholders Reconcile their Business Withdrawal with their Non-Competition Clause?

Annie-Claude Trudeau and Audrée Anne Barry, Co-Authors of the 2023-2024 Annotated Code of Civil Procedure

house-near-river

Watercourses and Ditches: What are the Risks of Building your Home Close to One of Them?

pierre-nuage

Contractors : Are you Responsible for the Quality of your Materials?

newspaper

Le Devoir is now a Registered Journalism Organization

The Risks of Miscommunication on a Construction Site

Chambers Canada Ranking: Five of our Lawyers Recognized

Interlocutory Injunctions: The Appearance of Right Criterion and its Nuances

Photo of Julie Doré

Julie Doré Takes Over Management of The BCF Business Law Firm

Three Up-and-Coming Lawyers Join BCF

Prospera – Quebec Economic Barometer

34 Professionals Stand Out in the Canadian Legal Lexpert Directory 2023

Julien Tricart, Member of the Meritas Sports Law Group

Court Alternatives to Add to Your Toolbox

Pride Month: Let’s Create an Inclusive Future

Canada’s Best Managed Companies: BCF Recognized for 16th Consecutive Year

Benchmark Litigation Canada's 2023 Edition: BCF Stands Out Once Again

Every Woman Counts

Strategic Forum on the Role Played by Businesses in the Fight Against Climate Change

BCF Partners with the Canadian Association of Black Lawyers to Promote Diversity in Québec Law Faculties

BCF's More Inclusive Approach: Improved Parental Leave

Shaun E. Finn Appointed to the Superior Court of Québec

How to Ensure a Business Succession?

Strategic Forum on Market Consolidation and Business Succession

Avoid and Prevent the Risk of Tax Litigation in Business Succession

Four New Partners Appointed

BCF Partners with the Clinique Juridique de Saint-Michel to Promote Access to Legal Studies for Young People from Diverse Communities

BCF Welcomes Two New Lawyers

Marie-Julie Lafleur Honoured as a Lexpert 2022 Rising Star

Dangerous Products Class Actions: Can Liability Be Unlimited?

Our Class Action Defence Group’s Expertise Featured in a New Volume of the Supreme Court Law Review

livres-echelle

Class Actions in Canada and Beyond: An Insightful Compilation on Class Actions

What’s the General Contractor’s Responsibility for Site Coordination?

Shaun E. Finn, Co-Author of In the Public Eye: Privacy, Personal Information, and High Stakes Litigation in the Canadian Public Sector

Should Using Personal Information Obtained Without Consent Be Grounds for Class Action Authorization?

André Ryan Receives the Advocatus Emeritus Honour

Five of our Lawyers Stand out in the 2023 Edition of the Chambers Canada Ranking

Is the Loss of Personal Information Sufficient to Justify the Success of a Class Action on the Merits?

Ready to Bid? Be Sure to Read the Tender Documents Carefully

43 BCF Professionals Stand Out with 78 Nominations in the 2023 Editions of Best Lawyers in Canada and Ones to Watch

Why Did the Superior Court of Québec Stay Some Sections of Bill 96?

Do Municipalities Have the Authority to Limit the Distribution of Printed Publicity within their Boundaries?

building

The “Arguable Case”: A Troubled History with an Uncertain Future

Can a General Contractor Significantly Increase Work Costs?

Shaun E. Finn, Co-Author of the 2022-2023 Annotated Code of Civil Procedure

Quebec Superior Court Addresses Legal Fees in Class Actions

Seven New Lawyers Join BCF

Post-Pandemic Trends and Negotiations in Commercial Leasing

Adoption of Bill 96: Be Ready

Commercial Leases: Where Do Things Stand Since the Pandemic?

Pride Month: The Value of Diversity

BCF, the 3rd Largest Law Firm in Québec

Canada’s Best Managed Companies: BCF Recognized for 15th Consecutive Year

Expropriation Compensation: How Far Does the “Highest and Best Use” Notion Extend?

Payment on Payment Clauses: Do You Know Your Rights?

BCF Stands Out in Benchmark Litigation Canada's 2022 Edition

lexpert

22 Professionals Stand Out in the Canadian Legal Lexpert Directory 2022

Court of Appeal Rules in Favour of Ville de Mont-Saint-Hilaire’s Real Estate Developers

BCF Welcomes Three New Partners

What Can a General Contractor Do to Be Relieved of His Duty to Advise?

Plan and Specification Errors: Who’s to Blame?

What Legal Recourse Do Citizens Have When Bothered by Municipal Work?

Important Victory for Développements St-Antoine in Fair and Equitable Expropriation Indemnity Case

Schools, COVID-19, and Class Actions: Some Lessons to Be Learned

A Second Edition for the Manuel de l’action collective

Did Airlines Fail in their Duty to Refund Tickets for Cancelled Flights Due to the Pandemic?

46 Lawyers of BCF Stand Out with 83 Recognitions in the 2022 Editions of Best Lawyers in Canada and Ones to Watch

Seven New Lawyers Join BCF

Shaun E. Finn Named Fellow of Litigation Counsel of America

Shaun E. Finn Co-Author of the Annotated Code of Civil Procedure 2021-2022

How to Navigate Québec's Complex Class Action System

A First in Quebec: COVID-19 Class Action Authorization Refused

Dismissal of a Class Action: How Far Does Police Liability Extend When Protesters Are Arrested?

Privacy and Data Protection Class Actions: Trends, Challenges and Best Practices

Our Partners Recognized in the 2021 Edition of Benchmark Litigation Canada Rankings

A First in Canada: Privacy Class Action Dismissed on the Merits

What Can Be Learned from Jurisprudential Developments in Public Contracts?

escalier

BCF Welcomes Seven New Lawyers

Supreme Court of Canada Takes Another Step towards the Guiding Principle of Good Faith in Contract Performance

Governance, a Key Element in Successful Business Succession Planning

Supreme Court Rules: Protection Against Cruel and Unusual Punishment Does Not Apply to Legal Persons

13 NHL Teams Move to Salary Arbitration Mode

An ever denser metropolis and the "Not in my backyard" syndrome

André Ryan and Shaun E. Finn, Co-Authors of the Book Québec Class – Actions - collectives au Québec

Shaun E. Finn Co-author of the Annotated Code of Civil Procedure 2020-2021

Regulations under Bill 102: A New Approach Based on the Environmental Risks of Each Project

Shaun E. Finn and Danielle Miller Olofsson Publish a Unique Practical Handbook on Privacy and Data-Protection Class Actions

23 BCF Partners Ranked in the Canadian Legal Lexpert Directory

36 Lawyers of BCF Stand Out with 52 Nominations in the 2021 Edition of Best Lawyers in Canada

BCF Welcomes Six New Lawyers in its Team

Hengyun International Investment Commerce Inc. Decision: A New Approach to Landlord-Tenant Relationships Arising from the Pandemic

Québec’s Bill 64 to Amend Data Protection Legislation: A Bill with Teeth?

How to Avoid Penal Liability in Your Post-COVID Activities

Criminal Offences in the Construction Industry: The Hidden Consequences of a Guilty Plea and Good Practices

COVID-19 and Construction: Impacts on Your Legal Hypothecs, RBQ Licences and Surety Bonds

COVID-19: Will the Pandemic Really Have an Impact on Your Contracts?

50 Questions You Need to Ask Yourself Before Doing Business in Canada

BCF Names 16 New Partners for Its 25th Anniversary

The Mike Ward Case: Why Did the Jokes About "Little Jérémy" Cross the Line According to the Court of Appeal?

Successful Judgment and Dismissal of a Claim Against Hydro-Québec and SEJB

Remember to Plan for Land Rehabilitation or for Management of Contaminated Soil in Your Projects

Are You a Leader or a Follower?Results of the Innovation Survey

The Autorité des Marchés Publics: What You Need to Know Regarding Major Projects and Request for Proposals

Environmental Impacts of Major Construction Projects: 5 Takeaways to Conduct Your Major Projects with Due Diligence

Infrastructure and Major Projects: Dare to Think Big

How to Deal With Changes During the Course of a Major Construction Project

Chambers Canada 2020: BCF Recognised in Corporate and Commercial Law

Strategic Forum on Innovation

Innovating to Survive: Are You a Leader or a Follower?

Legal Issues Surrounding the Industrial Revolution 4.0

Best Lawyers in Canada: 22 BCF Lawyers Recognized

How to React When your Photo is Reposted on a Satirical Website?

The Distressing Complexity of the Criteria for Authorizing a Class Action in Québec

Shaun E. Finn Co-author of the Annotated Code of Civil Procedure 2018-2019

Let’s Get the Leaders Talking: André Ryan Discusses his Career Path

The AMP's New Extrajudicial Complaint System Is Underway!

16 BCF Partners Recognized in the Prestigious Canadian Legal Lexpert Directory

Business Transfer: Ensuring the Continuation of Your Business

Define the Future we Want: Equal, Inclusive and Diverse

What are the risks of holding cryptocurrency funds on a platform such as QuadrigaCX?

piliers

Can a Demand for Share Redemption Lead to a Loss of Shareholder Attributes?

Get the latest thought leadership