Executive Summaries Apr 1, 2020

COVID-19: Will the Pandemic Really Have an Impact on Your Contracts?

In the face of the global outbreak of COVID-19, a question arises: what are the legal implications of a force majeure clause in your contracts or when your contract is silent in this regard?

As further detailed in our last article on force majeure, it seems that the COVID-19 pandemic will have a significant impact on the operations of Canadian companies and the measures they will have to take to respond to such repercussions. Invoking force majeure is a type of relief that companies should consider.

How Is the Concept of Force Majeure Assessed?

The concept of force majeure is a means of exemption from liability provided for in article 1470 of the Civil Code of Québec ("CCQ.") that can be invoked whether or not it is stipulated in your contract. Where applicable, force majeure enables the debtor of an obligation to justify the postponement or termination of his obligation due to an external factor. Since the parties must usually perform their obligations entirely and without delay, force majeure may be only be raised in exceptional circumstances. It is therefore interpreted and applied restrictively by the courts.

In order for this defence to be successfully invoked, the event in question must meet three cumulative criteria:

  • be "unforeseeable", that it was not foreseeable to a prudent and diligent person placed in the same circumstances;
  • be "irresistible", in other words, that the obligation cannot be performed fully or partly. Thus, the fact that a situation simply makes an obligation more difficult or more onerous to perform does not constitute force majeure;
  • cannot be due to a fault, negligence or a fact that is attributable to the debtor, but must be beyond his control, in order to meet the “externality” test.

Also, the concept of force majeure is not a matter of public order. Parties to a contract can negotiate and modulate its scope. It is therefore essential to refer to the specific wording of the clauses provided in each contract in order to verify the existence of such provisions and their scope.

What Is the Effect of an Event of Force Majeure?

Under Article 1693 CCQ., it is up to the debtor to prove force majeure. Under this provision, the debtor may be released from his obligation when an event qualified as force majeure occurs. It will also be the case where a creditor could not, in any event, have "benefited from performance of the obligation by reason of that superior force".

The debtor is therefore not required to perform an alternative obligation or to remedy the damage resulting from such non-performance. Discharge may be total, should performance prove to be unequivocally impossible, or partial, should the obligation be partially performed.

The inability to act may also be temporary, which has the effect of suspending the performance of the debtor's obligations. Examples could notably include certain performances that have been cancelled due to government directives issued in response to COVID-19 and that could (circumstances allowing) take place later in the year, or again, additional delays incurred in the production or shipment of certain goods from a supplier to the distributor.

In such a case - and if circumstances allow it - force majeure can suspend the performance of the debtor’s obligation and release the latter from liability incurred for the delay, without the possibility for the creditor to claim damages. On the other hand, the debtor must resume performance of his obligation when the event that caused the suspension of performance ceases. For instance, this could be at the time when sanitary measures will be  lifted.

Moreover, case law is clear that force majeure does not preclude the debtor and creditor to act in good faith and to mitigate their damages. It is therefore important that they take all reasonable measures at their disposal to limit the extent of their loss even in a case of force majeure.

Does the COVID-19 Pandemic Constitute a Force Majeure in Civil Law?

The qualification of a particular event as a force majeure is left to the courts’ discretion, particularly if the terms "pandemic(s)" or "epidemic(s)" are not expressly provided for in a specific exemption from liability clause in the contract in question (force majeure clause).

It is therefore analyzed on a case-by-case basis, depending on the degree and seriousness of the event.

State of emergency decrees, more specifically the Order in Council number 2020-008 of the Quebec Minister of Health and Social Services dated March 22, 2020 ordering the closure of non-essential businesses, could, in our view, constitute an unforeseeable fortuitous event that does not result from the the parties’ conduct.

It is also necessary to analyze whether this event can lead to a total or partial impossibility for the debtor to fulfill its obligation that he is seeking to be be exempted from. It will therefore be necessary to carry out a case-by-case analysis according to the developments of the evolving situation.

Although the outbreak of COVID-19 appears at first glance to meet the force majeure’s criteria of "unpredictability", "irresistibility" and "exteriority", it is difficult to determine at this time when or under what circumstances COVID-19 will be accepted as an exemption of liability.

What If My Contract Contains a Force Majeure Clause?

Each contracting party to a consensual contract governed by Quebec civil law will have to analyze the contractual rights and obligations arising therefrom, specifically with respect to situations or events that may be covered by force majeure. A specific analysis of each contract will be necessary to determine whether a party may, according to such contract, be exempted from performing its obligations in the current state of the global COVID-19 pandemic.

We note that many contracts provide a definition and a restrictive list of circumstances or events that may be considered as force majeure and thus justify non-performance or suspension of the obligation. For example, specific definitions such as "pandemic" or "epidemic" may be stipulated. In such circumstances, a notice mechanism will normally be provided to enable a contracting party to inform the other party of its intention not to perform a correlative obligation within a specified period of time . The parties will therefore have to be particularly attentive to this time limit and try as much as possible to observe it.

We therefore suggest a careful review of any ongoing contract, as our colleague Dominique Babin explains in her latest article.

What Happens If a Contract Is Silent With Respect to Force Majeure or If There Is No Written Contract Between the Parties?

The concept of force majeure is a legal means of exoneration from liability both in synallagmatic contracts through the application of Articles 1470, 1693 and 1694 CCQ, as well as in extra-contractual relations. In other words, it is not necessary for a force majeure clause to be included in the contract for a debtor to be able to invoke it and potentially be exempted from its performance.

It will therefore be up to the debtor to prove an unforeseeable, irresistible event outside the debtor's control in order to invoke such a defence.

As mentioned, a specific legal and factual analysis of the effects of the COVID-19 pandemic on the contractual situation between the parties will need to be carried out on a case-by-case basis. We invite you to contact a member of our Commercial Litigation team if you have any questions in this regard.

Stay on the lookout!

Subscribe to our communications and benefit from our market knowledge to identify new business opportunities, learn about innovative best practices and receive the latest developments. Discover our exclusive thought leadership and events.

Subscribe

You would also like

court

When Announcing a Price Comes at a Cost: The Court of Appeal Rules on Damages in Union des consommateurs v. Air Canada

BCF Recognized in the 2025 Edition of Benchmark Litigation Canada

Rencontre au Sommet

Rencontre au Sommet: Turning Economic Challenges into Collective Opportunities

lexpert

27 BCF Professionals Stand Out in the Canadian Legal Lexpert Directory 2025

Canada US flags

Customs Tariff Uncertainty: Impacts on Quebec Businesses

Analyse statistique - tarifs douaniers

Statistical analysis of the impact of U.S. tariffs on Quebec economy

Contrats commerciaux et echanges

Assessing and Mitigating the Impact of New U.S. Tariffs on Your Contractual Relationships

Lexology

6 BCF Professionals Recognized in Lexology Index Canada 2024

Entrepreneurship forum

Entrepreneurship Forum: Vision 2025

Athlete

Protecting Privacy in Sports – Don’t Wait to be Caught Flat-Footed!

Tech Forum 360

Tech 360 Forum: Growth and Inflection Points

Droit

E-Power Resources Inc. Secures Major Victory Against Dissident Shareholders

lexpert

28 Professionals Stand Out in the Canadian Legal Lexpert Directory 2024

Prospera: Québec’s Economic Barometer

Canada's Best Managed Companies: BCF Recognized for 17th Consecutive Year

paul et misha

BCF Strengthens its Expertise in Artificial Intelligence

stephanie-la-rocque

Stéphanie La Rocque Appointed to the Court of Québec

new-partners-2024

BCF Has Appointed Three New Partners

andre-ryan-client-choice

André Ryan Wins the Prestigious Client Choice Awards for 2023

Who’s Who Legal : 5 BCF Professionals Stand Out

BCF extends its Partnership with the Canadian Association of Black Lawyers to a Third Year

annie-claude-trudeau-rising-star-en

Annie-Claude Trudeau Honoured as a 2023 Lexpert Rising Star

Can Shareholders Reconcile their Business Withdrawal with their Non-Competition Clause?

Annie-Claude Trudeau and Audrée Anne Barry, Co-Authors of the 2023-2024 Annotated Code of Civil Procedure

pierre-nuage

Contractors : Are you Responsible for the Quality of your Materials?

newspaper

Le Devoir is now a Registered Journalism Organization

The Risks of Miscommunication on a Construction Site

Chambers Canada Ranking: Five of our Lawyers Recognized

Interlocutory Injunctions: The Appearance of Right Criterion and its Nuances

Photo of Julie Doré

Julie Doré Takes Over Management of The BCF Business Law Firm

Three Up-and-Coming Lawyers Join BCF

BCF Welcomes Five New Up-and-Coming Lawyers

Prospera – Quebec Economic Barometer

34 Professionals Stand Out in the Canadian Legal Lexpert Directory 2023

Julien Tricart, Member of the Meritas Sports Law Group

Non-Compliance Clauses in Construction Contracts: When Do They Apply?

Pride Month: Let’s Create an Inclusive Future

Canada’s Best Managed Companies: BCF Recognized for 16th Consecutive Year

Benchmark Litigation Canada's 2023 Edition: BCF Stands Out Once Again

Every Woman Counts

Strategic Forum on the Role Played by Businesses in the Fight Against Climate Change

BCF Partners with the Canadian Association of Black Lawyers to Promote Diversity in Québec Law Faculties

BCF's More Inclusive Approach: Improved Parental Leave

Shaun E. Finn Appointed to the Superior Court of Québec

How to Ensure a Business Succession?

Strategic Forum on Market Consolidation and Business Succession

Avoid and Prevent the Risk of Tax Litigation in Business Succession

Four New Partners Appointed

BCF Partners with the Clinique Juridique de Saint-Michel to Promote Access to Legal Studies for Young People from Diverse Communities

BCF Welcomes Two New Lawyers

Marie-Julie Lafleur Honoured as a Lexpert 2022 Rising Star

Dangerous Products Class Actions: Can Liability Be Unlimited?

Our Class Action Defence Group’s Expertise Featured in a New Volume of the Supreme Court Law Review

livres-echelle

Class Actions in Canada and Beyond: An Insightful Compilation on Class Actions

Shaun E. Finn, Co-Author of In the Public Eye: Privacy, Personal Information, and High Stakes Litigation in the Canadian Public Sector

Should Using Personal Information Obtained Without Consent Be Grounds for Class Action Authorization?

André Ryan Receives the Advocatus Emeritus Honour

Five of our Lawyers Stand out in the 2023 Edition of the Chambers Canada Ranking

Is the Loss of Personal Information Sufficient to Justify the Success of a Class Action on the Merits?

Ready to Bid? Be Sure to Read the Tender Documents Carefully

43 BCF Professionals Stand Out with 78 Nominations in the 2023 Editions of Best Lawyers in Canada and Ones to Watch

Why Did the Superior Court of Québec Stay Some Sections of Bill 96?

Do Municipalities Have the Authority to Limit the Distribution of Printed Publicity within their Boundaries?

building

The “Arguable Case”: A Troubled History with an Uncertain Future

Shaun E. Finn, Co-Author of the 2022-2023 Annotated Code of Civil Procedure

Quebec Superior Court Addresses Legal Fees in Class Actions

Seven New Lawyers Join BCF

Post-Pandemic Trends and Negotiations in Commercial Leasing

Adoption of Bill 96: Be Ready

Bill 96 is Passed: How Will It Affect Your Relations with Customers and Suppliers?

Commercial Leases: Where Do Things Stand Since the Pandemic?

Pride Month: The Value of Diversity

BCF, the 3rd Largest Law Firm in Québec

Canada’s Best Managed Companies: BCF Recognized for 15th Consecutive Year

BCF Stands Out in Benchmark Litigation Canada's 2022 Edition

BCF Welcomes Isabelle Métivier as a Real Estate Partner

lexpert

22 Professionals Stand Out in the Canadian Legal Lexpert Directory 2022

BCF Welcomes Three New Partners

BCF Recognized by the Globe and Mail as one of Canada’s top Law Firms

BCF Welcomes Julien Lefebvre as a Partner in its Business Law Team

What Legal Recourse Do Citizens Have When Bothered by Municipal Work?

Important Victory for Développements St-Antoine in Fair and Equitable Expropriation Indemnity Case

Schools, COVID-19, and Class Actions: Some Lessons to Be Learned

A Second Edition for the Manuel de l’action collective

Chambers Canada 2022: BCF Earned Band 1 Ranking in Québec for Corporate and Commercial Law

Did Airlines Fail in their Duty to Refund Tickets for Cancelled Flights Due to the Pandemic?

46 Lawyers of BCF Stand Out with 83 Recognitions in the 2022 Editions of Best Lawyers in Canada and Ones to Watch

Seven New Lawyers Join BCF

Shaun E. Finn Named Fellow of Litigation Counsel of America

Shaun E. Finn Co-Author of the Annotated Code of Civil Procedure 2021-2022

How to Navigate Québec's Complex Class Action System

A First in Quebec: COVID-19 Class Action Authorization Refused

Dismissal of a Class Action: How Far Does Police Liability Extend When Protesters Are Arrested?

Privacy and Data Protection Class Actions: Trends, Challenges and Best Practices

Our Partners Recognized in the 2021 Edition of Benchmark Litigation Canada Rankings

A First in Canada: Privacy Class Action Dismissed on the Merits

What Can Be Learned from Jurisprudential Developments in Public Contracts?

escalier

BCF Welcomes Seven New Lawyers

Supreme Court of Canada Takes Another Step towards the Guiding Principle of Good Faith in Contract Performance

Governance, a Key Element in Successful Business Succession Planning

Economic Recovery Strategic Forum

13 NHL Teams Move to Salary Arbitration Mode

An ever denser metropolis and the "Not in my backyard" syndrome

André Ryan and Shaun E. Finn, Co-Authors of the Book Québec Class – Actions - collectives au Québec

Adoption of Bill 42: Mandatory Disclosure of Nominee Agreement with Tax Consequences

Shaun E. Finn Co-author of the Annotated Code of Civil Procedure 2020-2021

Shaun E. Finn and Danielle Miller Olofsson Publish a Unique Practical Handbook on Privacy and Data-Protection Class Actions

23 BCF Partners Ranked in the Canadian Legal Lexpert Directory

36 Lawyers of BCF Stand Out with 52 Nominations in the 2021 Edition of Best Lawyers in Canada

BCF Welcomes Six New Lawyers in its Team

Hengyun International Investment Commerce Inc. Decision: A New Approach to Landlord-Tenant Relationships Arising from the Pandemic

Québec’s Bill 64 to Amend Data Protection Legislation: A Bill with Teeth?

How to Avoid Penal Liability in Your Post-COVID Activities

Criminal Offences in the Construction Industry: The Hidden Consequences of a Guilty Plea and Good Practices

COVID-19: Contractual and Practical Measures to Be Taken

Terranova Security Partners with Microsoft

50 Questions You Need to Ask Yourself Before Doing Business in Canada

COVID-19: When to Invoke Superior Force?

BCF once again ranks as one of Montreal's Top Employers

BCF Names 16 New Partners for Its 25th Anniversary

The Mike Ward Case: Why Did the Jokes About "Little Jérémy" Cross the Line According to the Court of Appeal?

Sundial and Crescita Sign Exclusive Partnership to Develop Cannabis and Hemp Topicals

Successful Judgment and Dismissal of a Claim Against Hydro-Québec and SEJB

Remember to Plan for Land Rehabilitation or for Management of Contaminated Soil in Your Projects

Are You a Leader or a Follower?Results of the Innovation Survey

The Autorité des Marchés Publics: What You Need to Know Regarding Major Projects and Request for Proposals

Infrastructure and Major Projects: Dare to Think Big

Chambers Canada 2020: BCF Recognised in Corporate and Commercial Law

Strategic Forum on Innovation

Innovating to Survive: Are You a Leader or a Follower?

Is Your Company Implementing a New Technology System? Remember to Protect Your Data

5G Technology Is Coming: Legal Questions Abound

Legal Issues Surrounding the Industrial Revolution 4.0

Best Lawyers in Canada: 22 BCF Lawyers Recognized

How to React When your Photo is Reposted on a Satirical Website?

The Distressing Complexity of the Criteria for Authorizing a Class Action in Québec

Shaun E. Finn Co-author of the Annotated Code of Civil Procedure 2018-2019

André Ryan: The Grand Prix Lawyer

Let’s Get the Leaders Talking: André Ryan Discusses his Career Path

Health Canada Is Changing its Cannabis Licensing Process

The AMP's New Extrajudicial Complaint System Is Underway!

16 BCF Partners Recognized in the Prestigious Canadian Legal Lexpert Directory

Business Transfer: Ensuring the Continuation of Your Business

Define the Future we Want: Equal, Inclusive and Diverse

What are the risks of holding cryptocurrency funds on a platform such as QuadrigaCX?

piliers

Can a Demand for Share Redemption Lead to a Loss of Shareholder Attributes?

Get the latest thought leadership