Executive Summaries Apr 22, 2021

Human Blood in Your Nike: Satanic Shoes or Work of Art?

Last month, a certain pair of shoes caused controversy. In fact, the said shoes are the Nike Air Max 97 model that the art collective MSCHF (an abbreviation for Miscellaneous Mischief) has modified, notably by adding liquid composed of a drop of human blood in the soles.

A reference to a passage from the Bible also appears on the shoes, verse 10:18 of the Gospel according to Luke, which reads: "And he said to them, I saw Satan falling like lightning from heaven". The collective stayed in the symbolism of hell by adding a pentagram and an upside-down cross. The shoes were promoted in collaboration with the rapper Lil Nas X, who had launched his latest song a few days before the launch of the shoes. MSCHF released 666 pairs of shoes at a price of US$1,018 each, and they sold out in less than a minute. Since then, their resale price has risen dramatically, reaching up to US$2,999.

Nike promptly filed a lawsuit against MSCHF, demanding, among other things, that it cease producing, distributing, selling and promoting any product under its trademark and claiming damages for its financial losses.

Confusion for Consumers

Nike alleged in its claim that the shoes were likely to cause confusion among consumers, who would see a link between MSCHF's products and Nike. Indeed, despite the modifications made to the shoes, the original model was recognizable, and the Nike logo was clearly visible. It seems that following the product launch, some people were really confused, such as mixed martial arts athlete Jon Jones, who announced to his followers on Twitter that he was planning to burn all his Nike shoes.

A judge ruled in favour of Nike by granting an interlocutory injunction against MSCHF, prohibiting the production and sale of satanic shoes, judging that the transformation was not sufficient to give the shoes the status of a work of art.

MSCHF, for its part, argued that it had never claimed to be associated with Nike and that the shoes were rather a form of artistic expression aimed at criticizing the fact that many well-known brands absurdly associate themselves with cultural movements.

Arguments based on the first sale doctrine could also have been raised in this action. This principle means that any user can resell a product that he or she has legally purchased, such as a used car, at will. However, overly modified products cannot benefit from the doctrine, as they become new products. Outside of the United States, this is referred to as the principle of exhaustion of rights, which is generally recognized in Canada, although it is not provided by Law. However, it is difficult to know whether the Court would have decided the issue in the same way in Canada because, even if the legal principles in trademarks are similar to those in the United States, there are important nuances. Indeed, to play devil's advocate, we could argue that the consumer is not confused when he thinks he is buying Nike shoes and he is actually buying Nike shoes.

Ultimately, the Court will not have to issue a final judgment in this matter, as an out-of-court settlement agreement has been reached between Nike and MSCHF. Under this agreement, MSCHF has agreed to offer refunds to all customers who wish to return the cursed shoes to MSCHF, in an effort to remove them from circulation. However, considering the value of the shoes, it is reasonable to believe that few customers will return their purchase. Nevertheless, Nike will certainly have accomplished its goal of distancing itself as much as possible from this initiative.

Stay on the lookout!

Subscribe to our communications and benefit from our market knowledge to identify new business opportunities, learn about innovative best practices and receive the latest developments. Discover our exclusive thought leadership and events.

Subscribe

You would also like

Propriété intellectuelle

BCF Professionals Recognized Among the World’s Leading IP Experts

IAM Patent 1000: Seven partners recognized among the most prestigious patent professionals

echec

Tariff Issues and New Marketing Strategy: Don’t Forget the Impact on Your Trademarks

BCF is recognized in the 2025 edition of the Chambers Global directory

Three Partners Ranked Among the Top Trademark Professionals in the World Trademark Review 1000

Propriété intellectuelle

Wine, Beer, Juice, Water - Make these Beverages, With or Without Alcohol, Part of Your Trademark Resolutions for 2025!

Lexology

6 BCF Professionals Recognized in Lexology Index Canada 2024

Entrepreneurship forum

Entrepreneurship Forum: Vision 2025

Does Your Font Add Character to Your Trademark?

BCF Stands Out in Legal 500 Canada

Tech Forum 360

Tech 360 Forum: Growth and Inflection Points

Registre marque de commerce

Protecting Trademarks on Online Platforms: Walmart and Temu

IAM Patent 1000: Six Partners Rank Among the Most Prestigious Patent Professionals

Prospera: Québec’s Economic Barometer

Canada's Best Managed Companies: BCF Recognized for 17th Consecutive Year

Three Partners Ranked Among the Top Trademark Professionals in the World Trademark Review 1000

What if your Creativity Could Take the Form of a Non-traditional Trademark Registration?

BCF extends its Partnership with the Canadian Association of Black Lawyers to a Third Year

Adopting a Green Trademark, or the Potential Limits of Virtue

IP_Stars

Managing IP: 5 of our professionals recognized as IP stars

co-branding-stones

Co-branding : Beneficial – Under Certain Conditions

Chambers Canada Ranking: Five of our Lawyers Recognized

Photo of Julie Doré

Julie Doré Takes Over Management of The BCF Business Law Firm

Influencers and Counterfeiting: Risks and Consequences

Monitoring Third Parties’ Use of Similar Trademarks is Essential to Safeguarding your Rights and Market Share

Business black folders on table

Adjustment of Trademarks Fees – Be Prepared

hands-signing-documents

Free Trade Agreements: Their Potential Impact on Your Trademark Protection Strategy Abroad

Prospera – Quebec Economic Barometer

Julien Tricart, Member of the Meritas Sports Law Group

Pride Month: Let’s Create an Inclusive Future

BIMI (Brand Indicators for Message Identification): Registered Trademark Required

NFTs and Terms of Use: They Go Hand in Hand

Canada’s Best Managed Companies: BCF Recognized for 16th Consecutive Year

Louboutin: The Red Sole Celebrates its 30th Anniversary

Industrial Design and Trademarks Go Hand in Hand

The Idea of a New Mark Is Not Enough

Every Woman Counts

Strategic Forum on the Role Played by Businesses in the Fight Against Climate Change

BCF Partners with the Canadian Association of Black Lawyers to Promote Diversity in Québec Law Faculties

How can you Legally Protect your Artificial Intelligence?

Trademarks and changes to the Charter of the French Language – Be ready!

BCF's More Inclusive Approach: Improved Parental Leave

Shaun E. Finn Appointed to the Superior Court of Québec

Two Partners Ranked Among the Top Trademark Professionals in the World Trademark Review 1000

How to Ensure a Business Succession?

Strategic Forum on Market Consolidation and Business Succession

When Trademarks and Geography Don’t Mix

BCF Partners with the Clinique Juridique de Saint-Michel to Promote Access to Legal Studies for Young People from Diverse Communities

The Trap of Using Laudatory Trademarks

Five of our Lawyers Stand out in the 2023 Edition of the Chambers Canada Ranking

Master Classes in Intellectual Property

43 BCF Professionals Stand Out with 78 Nominations in the 2023 Editions of Best Lawyers in Canada and Ones to Watch

Adoption of Bill 96: Be Ready

Adoption of Bill 96: How Will Your Trademarks and Public Signs Be Affected?

Pride Month: The Value of Diversity

Derivative Products and Services: Anticipating the Possibilities for Your Trademarks

BCF, the 3rd Largest Law Firm in Québec

Canada’s Best Managed Companies: BCF Recognized for 15th Consecutive Year

Trademarks and Reserved Designations: Not Everyone Can Make “Farmstead Cheese”

Intellectual Property and Emojis: Who Owns the Smiley Face?

Trademarks on the Beverage Market, Alcoholic or Not: Avoid Drinking the Cup

A Few Things to Consider for Your Pharmaceutical Trademark

Three Partners Ranked Among the Top Trademark Professionals in the World Trademark Review 1000

Trademarks Modernization Act Comes into Effect: Time to Redefine Your Trademark Protection Strategy in the United States

Tiffany and Co.’s Blue Box.: Story of an Iconic Trademark

NFTs and Intellectual Property: Pulp Fiction at the Heart of a Dispute

Trademark Infringement and Passing Off: Trademark Registration as a Full Defence

Almost Half of the Canadian Businesses Have Little Knowledge of Intellectual Property: Be in the Other Half!

IAM Strategy 300: Our Partner Ilya Kalnish Is Recognized As One of the World's Top IP Strategists

Rihanna Billionaire: Cosmetics, Licences and Trademarks

Cannabis Industry Still Growing Strong

A Lipstick Like No Other: Guerlain Obtains Registration of a Three-Dimensional Trademark

The Official and Common Language of Québec Act: How Will it Affect Your Trademarks and Public Signage?

Halston: The Man Who Sold His Name... and His Mark

France: Easier Invalidity and Revocation Proceedings for Non-Used Marks

Accelerating the Registration of Your Trademark Is Now (Potentially) Possible!

What if Protecting your Trademark Became Easier in the United States?

Merger between La Capitale and SSQ Insurance results in the creation of Beneva, the largest mutual in Canada

Intellectual Property: An Incentive to Create and Invent

The Registration of a Trade Name with the Business Registry: A False Sense of Security

COVID-19: Impacts and Considerations for Your Trademarks

Infringement of Your Rights by an App: Let Apple Help You!

Trademarks Trolls: A Real Threat to Canadian Brand Owners?

Frédéric Dionne appointed to INTA’s Emerging Issues Committee

Sarah Hébert-Tremblay Appointed to the IPIC’s Trademark Committee

Are You a Leader or a Follower?Results of the Innovation Survey

November 24 Is Approaching Fast: Is Your Commercial Sign Compliant?

Trademarks: Now Is the Time To Be More Strategic Than Ever

Strategic Forum on Innovation

Innovating to Survive: Are You a Leader or a Follower?

BCF Appointed Canada’s Exclusive Representative to the Unifab College of Experts

Innovation Needs Protection

What About the Name of Your Innovation?

Trademarks in Canada: What You Need To Do Before June 17 To Save Costs

cellphone

Make the Most of Your Brand on Instagram

bcf-ilya-kalnish-client-choice

Partner Ilya Kalnish Wins the Prestigious Customer Choice Awards 2019

Amendments to the Canadian Trademarks Act Coming Into Force on June 17, 2019

lumieres plafond

Amendment to the Canadian Trademarks Act Aiming to Prevent the Misuse of the Registration Process

Impact of the United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement on Intellectual Property Rights

Registering Your Products on Amazon: Practical Trademark Considerations

Trademarks and Cannabis: Tailoring a Strategy

Céline Tremblay Is Joining BCF’s Intellectual Property Team!

The Challenges of Agri-Food Marketing Under CETA

Get the latest thought leadership